French History

Topic has 79 replies.

Print Search
Sort Posts:    
   01/02/2008, 23:52
fieldwalker is not online. Last active: 29/01/2008 14:32:24 fieldwalker

Not Ranked
Joined on 29/01/2008
Posts 2
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote

Bixy, if you research the subject, you will find the majority of answers to your own questions!

Look closely within the ruined shells and you'll see more than a few pans, bicycles, and the odd sewing machine. Most of the buildings have required some form of strengthening over the years, and this is evident from the large concrete frames which can be seen within the structures.In order for remedial work to be carried out to preserve the village, in many cases large amounts of rubble needed to be cleared before work could take place.

These buildings were torched in an attempt to destroy everything, and there is no better evidence of the ferocity of the effects of fire than the molten mass of metal that was once the church bell.

Many artifacts were in fact recovered, some of which can be seen on display in the cemetery. 

 

 


   Report 
   02/02/2008, 19:45
bixy is not online. Last active: 01/07/2008 06:25:22 bixy

Top 500 Posts
Joined on 12/09/2004
Posts 268
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote
But what happened to the hundreds of thousands of tiles?

Patrick

   Report 
   02/02/2008, 20:02
Hoddy is not online. Last active: 14/07/2008 13:49:22 Hoddy

Top 75 Posts
Joined on 23/08/2004
.....Forum Moderator..... NW Leics/SE Dordogne
Posts 2,086
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote
I think Fieldwalker has already given an excellent answer to this. The ground would have had to be cleared in order for the strengthening work to be carried out. Most of the buildings would have fallen down by now if they'd just been left.
To say that the village should be preserved just as it was does not mean that it is just left to crumble. Obviously, as I said earlier, some conservation work has to be done. If it hadn't been, then no doubt the whole place would be overgrown by now. That's why I wouldn't mind paying an entrance fee.

Hoddy



   Report 
   03/02/2008, 15:49
cowoman is not online. Last active: 09/04/2008 22:38:35 cowoman



Not Ranked
Joined on 08/04/2007
WR9 and 87
Posts 232
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote

When we went I was amazed that the Brits hadnt got their scaffolding out to start renovation work.If it wasnt such a sad story,i am sure i would have seen some new roofs going on

 


   Report 
   03/02/2008, 15:52
Cathy is not online. Last active: 13/05/2008 17:50:34 Cathy



Top 75 Posts
Joined on 07/03/2006
Mostly near Bordeaux; Sometimes near Bristol
Posts 1,688
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote

Presumably the message take home from Oradour is not in the detail of the buildings but the symbolism of the village?

 


Cathy
-----
Your children won't remember you ironing their pyjamas but they will remember you reading them a bedside story.
   Report 
   03/02/2008, 15:57
DerekJ is not online. Last active: 13/07/2008 13:58:14 DerekJ



Not Ranked
Joined on 19/10/2007
Surrey and the Lot
Posts 157
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote
 Cathy wrote:

Presumably the message take home from Oradour is not in the detail of the buildings but the symbolism of the village?

 



I would have thought that very true. If you go to somewhere like Dachau you will find that many of the building no longer exist (just the foundations) but the sense of desolation and pain is still all consuming.

Derek
   Report 
   04/02/2008, 11:26
dwmcn is not online. Last active: 21/01/2008 11:56:14 dwmcn

Not Ranked
Joined on 21/04/2006
Posts 102
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote

Cows can have hooves and hoofs, but houses can only have roofs, not rooves.

 


   Report 
   04/02/2008, 18:35
cowoman is not online. Last active: 09/04/2008 22:38:35 cowoman



Not Ranked
Joined on 08/04/2007
WR9 and 87
Posts 232
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote
 dwmcn wrote:

Cows can have hooves and hoofs, but houses can only have roofs, not rooves.

 

thanks for that


   Report 
   07/02/2008, 11:04
dwmcn is not online. Last active: 21/01/2008 11:56:14 dwmcn

Not Ranked
Joined on 21/04/2006
Posts 102
Re: Oradour sur Glane
Reply Quote
I'm not really a pedant. I get enough of that on another forum. I was just moooooved to reply by your photograph.
   Report 
  Page 7 of 9 (80 items) « First ... < 5 6 7 8 9 >
France Forum » French Culture » French History » Oradour sur Glane

Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems

Please note that any unsolicited advertising will be removed